The Capetian Dynasty
A study aid on the Capetian kings of France, for Canto XX of Dante's Purgatorio.
In Purgatorio XX, Hugh Capet presents not a complete history of the French monarchy, but a focus on those Capetian rulers or princes whose actions exemplify the avarice and political corruption that Hugh believes have poisoned Christendom.
| Esolen Lines | King / Prince | Historical Identity | Hugh Capet’s Accusation or Commentary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 43-45 | Hugh Capet | Founder of the Capetian dynasty (r. 987-996) | Identifies himself as “the root of that evil plant” whose descendants have corrupted Christendom. [en.wikisource.org], [sacred-texts.com] |
| 46-48 | The “Louises and Philips” | Collective reference to the Capetian kings of France | Hugh notes that from him descended the royal line that ruled France. The reference is general, setting up the ensuing indictment of the dynasty. [en.wikisource.org] |
| 61-66 | Hugh Capet’s descendants generally | The expanding Capetian monarchy | Hugh laments how the French royal house gained power and wealth and extended its influence beyond France. [en.wikisource.org], [thedivinesummary.com] |
| 67-69 | Charles I of Anjou | Brother of Louis IX; King of Sicily and Naples | “Charles came to Italy.” Hugh condemns his intervention in Italian affairs and specifically recalls his role in the defeat and execution of Conradin, the last Hohenstaufen heir. [thedivinesummary.com], [historyinbooks.com] |
| 70-72 | Charles I of Anjou | Same | Hugh repeats a medieval accusation that Charles was responsible for the poisoning of Thomas Aquinas. [thedivinesummary.com] |
| 73-75 | Charles of Valois | Son of Philip III | Entered Florence “with no weapon but the lance of Judas.” Hugh condemns his false promises of peace and his role in overthrowing the White Guelfs, leading to Dante’s exile. [thedivinesummary.com], [historyinbooks.com] |
| 76-78 | Charles II of Anjou | Son of Charles I | Hugh portrays him as driven by greed and political bargaining. Dante alludes to his treatment of his daughter as an object of dynastic exchange. [thedivinesummary.com] |
| 79-81 | Charles II of Anjou | Same | Continues the condemnation of his avarice and the dishonoring of royal responsibilities for gain. [thedivinesummary.com] |
| 82-84 | Philip IV (“Philip the Fair”) | King of France (r. 1285-1314) | Hugh announces the advent of a ruler whose crimes exceed those of his predecessors. [thedivinesummary.com], [historyinbooks.com] |
| 85-90 | Philip IV (“the new Pilate”) | Same | Hugh likens Philip to Pilate because of his attack on Pope Boniface VIII. The king extends his grasp even against Christ’s vicar. [thedivinesummary.com], [historyinbooks.com] |
| 91-93 | Philip IV | Same | Allusion to the outrage at Anagni (1303), in which French agents seized and humiliated Boniface VIII. Hugh regards this as a sacrilegious assault on Christ Himself. [thedivinesummary.com], [historyinbooks.com] |
Summary
Hugh Capet’s historical survey concentrates on four principal descendants:
- 1. Charles I of Anjou - conquest, violence, and the death of Conradin.
- 2. Charles II of Anjou - dynastic bargaining and avarice.
- 3. Charles of Valois - destruction of Florence under a false guise of peacemaking.
- 4. Philip IV the Fair - the supreme example of royal greed and sacrilege, especially in the humiliation of Boniface VIII.