Italian Renaissance Daily Plans
Twelve days of lesson plans for the Italian Renaissance unit: Durant on the Renaissance man and woman, Petrarch and his sonnets, and Boccaccio’s Decameron.
Day 1
Activities:
-
A. Distribute “Student Information” sheets
-
B. Go over the course outline.
-
I. Texts
-
A. The Canterbury Tales - Geoffrey Chaucer
-
B. Antony and Cleopatra - William Shakespeare
-
C. Life Is a Dream - Calderon de la Barca
-
D. Amadeus - Peter Shaffer
-
E. The Queen of Spades - Alexander Pushkin
-
F. Cyrano de Bergerac - Edmond Rostand
-
G. The Death of Ivan Ilych - Leo Tolstoy
-
H. A Canticle for Leibowitz - Walter Miller, Jr.
* There will also be handouts of selections from various writers along with background sheets and study guides.
-
-
II. Objectives
- A. To become familiar with a selection of great literature, art, and music from periods running from the Italian Renaissance to the present
- B. To develop an appreciation for the humanities
- C. To expand your vocabulary (both common and technical terms)
- D. To develop open-mindedness while also committing to a position
- E. To practice responsibility and courtesy in conduct and attitude
-
III. Activities
- A. Reading both complete works and excerpts
- B. Viewing works of art for later identification
- C. Discussing the history and philosophy of the assigned periods
- D. Participating actively in discussion
- E. Writing essays and weekly summaries
-
IV. Materials (to be brought to class each day)
- A. all current reading assignments (including books and handouts)
- B. a working pen (blue or black ink only)
- C. a notebook for taking copious reading notes and class notes
- D. non-spiral composition paper
-
V. Expectations
This is a weighted phase 5 English class.
The work is both challenging and demanding.
There will be little or no extra credit.
It is a class that you elected to take.
That means no griping, complaining, or whining about the course work. It also means that I will encourage courteous and concrete criticism.
Such communication is the primary purpose of the weekly summaries.
I expect you to come to class prepared for the day’s work.
I will not write passes to lockers.
Any assignment not submitted when called for will be penalized 10% for each day late.
I expect you to be in your seat when the tardy bell rings.
Most days will begin with a quiz over the reading.
These quizzes are designed to measure your reading skills: WE WILL NOT BE GOING OVER THE MATERIALS BEFORE THE QUIZZES.
-
-
D. Distribute “Renaissance Man and Renaissance Woman.” You will find these stapled and in a pile on my desk or on one of the tables along the wall.
Assignment for next class meeting: Read “Renaissance Man and Renaissance Woman” by Will Durant. Answer the eight study questions on the front of the packet.
Day 2
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read “Renaissance Man and Renaissance Woman” by Will Durant. Answer the eight study questions on the front of the packet. Read the essay assignment and the explanation of that assignment at the end of that packet.
Activities:
- A. Administer quiz over the reading. [These can be found in the third drawer of the filing cabinet - LABELLED 3 - in a pink-tabbed folder labelled “DURANT” toward the front of the drawer.]
- B. Go over the answers to the study questions. [The following are, for the most part, drawn directly from the essays. Use my responses to guide the students’ responses.]
Renaissance Man
- 1. What two factors combined to produce “the man of the Renaissance”?
“Intellectual enfranchisement” and “moral release.” The first refers to the growth of learning, especially the shift from an almost exclusive interest in ecclesiastical learning to a broader interest in the humanities. The second refers to a throwing off of the curbing effects of traditional values as established by the medieval Church.
- 2. What are two foci of this universal man’s personality?
The two foci were “intellectual and moral audacity,” a marked boldness in thinking and conduct.
What word best describes his spirit?
“It was a recklessly individualistic spirit,” a spirit that rebelled against tradition - especially the tradition of anonymous humility.
(How has the man in the city changed? The man in the Church? The man in the arts?)
(“In the city such a man might lead a turbulent faction…in the Church he would gather a hundred benefices under his cassock, and use his wealth to climb to power.” “In art he was no longer an artisan working anonymously with others on a collective enterprise, as in the Middle Ages; he was ‘a single and separate person.’ who stamped his character upon his works, signed his name to his paintings, even, now and then, carved it on his statues, like Michelangelo on the Pieta.”)
At the end of the second paragraph, what traits does Durant list for the “Renaissance man”?
Durant’s list of traits for the “Renaissance man” includes constant movement, discontent (“fretting at limits”), bold, decisive, eloquent, skilled, educated (longing to be a “universal man,” “acquainted with literature and philosophy”), and versatile (“at home with women in the palace and with soldiers in the camp”).
- 3. What was his goal?
His goal was the successful expression of his personality.
What qualities does Durant regard as the virtues of the Renaissance man?
Durant regards the “Renaissance Man’s” virtues as realism, good manners, gracefulness, energy, strength of character, sense of purpose (“direction”), virtu (“the Roman conception of manliness”), unity of will, skill, intelligence, compassion.
With what sense did he replace the moral?
According to Durant, the “Renaissance Man” replaced the moral sense with the aesthetic. Though in the extreme this appreciation of the beautiful led to vanity and narcissism, but in its more positive manifestations promoted an appreciation of both women and the arts.
- 4. With what simple metaphor does Durant differentiate medieval from Renaissance man?
“The Middle Ages had said - or had pretended to say - No to life. The Renaissance, with all its heart and soul and might, said Yes.”
Durant’s metaphor points up the medieval emphasis on the world to come in contrast to the Renaissance emphasis on the world of the here and now.
However, it is important to note that despite his very modern-sounding values in many respects, the Renaissance Man maintained an interest in and a comparatively greater devotion to religious principles.
Renaissance Woman
- 1. What was the major emphasis of a woman’s training?
“A girl of good family was carefully trained for success in getting and keeping a prosperous mate; this was the major subject of her curriculum.”
What else did her education include?
Her curriculum also included some Latin, Greek and Roman history, literature, and philosophy, music for performance, and sculpture or painting.
What is Durant’s summation of her?
“…the educated woman of the Renaissance retained her femininity, her Christianity, and its moral code; and this gave her a union of culture and character that made her irresistible to the higher Renaissance man.”
- 2. In what ways were Renaissance women like contemporary women?
Like contemporary women, Renaissance women dyed their hair, wore wigs, loved perfumes, used diverse cosmetics, adorned themselves with jewelry and the best clothing. They also seemed to enjoy what some of their contemporary critics might have compared to a Madonna-like flair for undress and a pathological pursuit of a thin figure.
- 3. To what extent did Renaissance women reach toward equality?
Renaissance women conversed with men as intellectual equals in discussions of literature and philosophy. Some governed states, fought in combat, and pursued even the immodest humor that has always been a pursuit of men but without losing her modesty or charm. Many inspired the confidence in men by their virtue, their intellect, and their piety. A few even excelled despite masculine dominance as poets, artists, and philosophers.
- 4. How was this heightening of upper class women accomplished?
“The educated women of the Renaissance emancipated themselves without any propaganda of emancipation, purely by their intelligence, character, and tact, and by the heightened sensitivity of the men to their tangible and intangible charms.” In other words, they cultivated their minds, their passions, their personalities on their own in response to a new level of male awareness of their minds as well as of their bodies.
What was the effect of all this on the men?
“…men ceased to be coarse and crude, and were molded to finer manners and speech; the civilization, with all its laxity and violence, took on a grade and refinement such as it had not known in Europe for a thousand years.”
According to Durant, the effect of freed femininity is to sensitize men and enhance civilization.
Assignment for next class meeting: Do pre-writing (freewriting, brainstorming/listing, clustering, asking questions, cubing, and so forth) to answer the question, “What are the qualities that distinguish the “Contemporary Person” from the Renaissance Man or Woman that Durant describes?” This prewriting is due AT THE BEGINNING of the period tomorrow.
Day 3
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have done the pre-writing (freewriting, brain-storming/listing, clustering, asking questions, cubing, and so forth) to answer the question, “What are the qualities that distinguish the “Contemporary Person” from the Renaissance Man or Woman that Durant describes?”
Activities:
- A. Collect the homework. [If anyone turns in this assignment after you have collected it, please write the word LATE and the time at which he or she submitted the work to you.]
- B. Have a student go to the board and list his or her “groups or types” of influential contemporary individuals. Then have the rest of the students - one at a time - tell the student at the board their “groups or types” so that the recorder may add those to the list already started. Remind the students not to repeat subjects already listed.
- C. Ask the students to get out a fresh sheet of paper. Tell them to select the three most influential of the listed “groups or types” and to write the label of one group at the top of the blank piece of paper, that of the second group about half the way down the sheet, and that of a third at the top of the other side of the paper. Allow about 1 min. for this activity.
- D. Going around the room, ask each student the three subjects he or she recorded on the blank paper. Place a tally mark beside a subject each time it is mentioned. When you have gone completely around the room, determine which three subjects received the most votes. Erase the list and write the three most chosen subjects on the board - one on the far left, one in the middle, and one on the far right. Allow about 15 min. for this activity.
- E. Instruct the students to list the qualities of each of the three subjects beneath the labels on their blank sheets of paper.
- 1. First, consider politics: is the group or type predominantly radical, liberal, moderate, conservative, reactionary, or non-political? Is politics at the heart of the group’s influence or significance?
- 2. Next, consider religion: is the group connected to an established world religion or is it a relatively new religion, are its beliefs traditional or iconoclastic, is the group oriented more toward spirituality or more toward social welfare or a balance of both? Is religion at the heart of the group’s influence or significance?
- 3. Next, consider commerce: is the group capitalistic, socialistic, communistic or fascist; is trade significant to their goals or practices; are they primarily concerned with economic matters; are they materialistic? Is commerce at the heart of the group’s influence or significance?
- 4. Next, consider social qualities: is the group oriented toward the concerns of self, of ethnic group, of others in general, or of the human race at large; what values or goals does the group promote or model by their rhetoric and behavior? Are social attitudes at the heart of the group’s influence or significance?
- 5. Next, consider military qualities: is the group belligerent, defensive, neutral, or pacifistic; does the group distinguish between just and unjust wars; does the group believe in intervention or isolationism? Are military concerns at the heart of the group’s influence or significance?
- 6. Next, consider personal qualities: does the group over all tend to express a basic personality type (for example, extroverted, introverted, risk-taking, cautious, overbearing, self-effacing, educated, uneducated, and so forth)? Are personal qualities at the heart of the group’s influence or significance?
- 7. Finally, consider any other qualities you can think of: ethical standards, philosophy, education, recreation, technology, and so forth.
- F. Send three students to the board to record all their responses for the group written at the far left of the board. Send three more to do the same for the group written in the middle. Send three more to do the same for the group written at the far right. Send all nine students at the same time. Allow about 2 min. for this activity.
- G. Encourage the other students to evaluate the three lists now on the board. They should make suggestions for additions, deletions, and changes in wording. Allow about 10 min. for this activity. Encourage everyone to make the same additions, deletions, or changes in their own lists - if they agree with them.
- H. Ask the students to answer each of the following questions for one of the three groups. Encourage a number of responses to demonstrate the potential for variety and differences.
- 1. What picture or image of the group do you get from the list you have generated?
- 2. What idea, word, or phrase emerges in your mind as you consider the qualities on the list?
- 3. Which details would have to be included in a description of the group?
- 4. Which group of details is the longest? What do those details have in common?
- 5. What part of the subject interests you most or inspires the most concern in you?
- 6. Who are the people of today who most clearly represent these qualities and this group?
- 7. Does your group and its influence begin in the nineties, the eighties, the seventies, or the sixties?
Assignment for next class meeting: Read item II - C of the prewriting directions. [It begins at the bottom of the first page on prewriting and continues for the next two pages.] Choose a pattern of organization for your essay. Write a thesis statement. Make an outline for your paper.
Day 4
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have chosen a pattern of organization, written a thesis statement, and made an outline for their paper.
Activities:
- A. Collect the homework. [If anyone turns in this assignment after you have collected it, please write the word LATE and the time at which he or she submitted the work to you.]
- B. On the left side of the board write the letter A, followed by the label Renaissance. On the right side of the board write the letter B, followed by the label Contemporary.
- 1. Under Renaissance list the following
- 1) Individualistic spirit
- a) Departure from medieval anonymity
- b) Interest in appearance and image
- c) Desire to master many skills
- 2) Self-expressive
- a) Bold and decisive
- b) Eloquent - bel parlare
- c) Love of artistry
- 3) Personal virtues
- a) Good manners and gracefulness
- b) Strength of character and sense of purpose
- c) Virtu
- d) Compassion
- 1) Individualistic spirit
- 2. Under Contemporary list the following
- 1) Characteristic spirit: _________________________
- a)
- b)
- c)
- 2) Personality traits: _________________________
- a)
- b)
- c)
- 3) Personal virtues
- a)
- b)
- c)
- d)
- 1) Characteristic spirit: _________________________
- 1. Under Renaissance list the following
- C. Ask the students to fill in the blank spaces - both the numbered and the lettered spaces. Allow about 10 min. for this activity.
- D. Explain that the two rough outlines on the board could serve as the plan for organizing the two body paragraphs of an essay controlled by the “divided pattern.”
- E. Write the following on the board.
-
I. Characteristic spirit
- A. Renaissance: individualistic
- 1. Departure from medieval anonymity
- 2. Interest in appearance and image
- 3. Desire to master many skills
- B. Contemporary: _________________________
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- A. Renaissance: individualistic
-
II. Personality traits
- A. Renaissance
- 1. Self-expressive
- 2. Bold and decisive
- 3. Eloquent - bel parlare
- 4. Love of artistry
- B. Contemporary
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
- A. Renaissance
-
III. Personal virtues
- A. Renaissance
- 1. Good manners and gracefulness
- 2. Strength of character and sense of purpose
- 3. Virtu
- 4. Compassion
- B. Contemporary
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- A. Renaissance
-
- F. Explain that the rough outline on the board could serve as the plan for organizing the two body paragraphs of an essay controlled by the “alternating pattern.”
- G. Ask the students to answer each of the following questions in regard to the information contained in the outline currently on the board.
- 1. Do the Renaissance and Contemporary Person sound more similar or more dissimilar?
- 2. What major points will a paper based on this model cover?
- 3. What impression does the information regarding the Contemporary Person make on you? What details will get that same impression across to the reader of your essay?
- H. Instruct students to write a thesis statement that asserts that the Renaissance and Contemporary Person they have selected is quite similar despite the differences in customs and culture or that they are quite dissimilar despite certain similarities. [Remind students never to use the words “The purpose of this essay is…” or “In this essay I will show.” In fact, they should not make announcements of any kind in their essays.]
- I. Instruct students to make an outline that follows the instructions laid out in the prewriting directions. Remind them that they will have to add the specific details that they will use to prove the points they have outlined in their writing plans.
Assignment for next class meeting: Write the first draft of the assigned essay.
Day 5
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have written the first draft of the assigned essay.
Activities:
- A. Collect the essays by instructing the students to pass forward their papers, placing theirs on the top of the stack as the stacks come forward. This will keep them in alphabetical order. Then collect the papers starting at your left, and placing each row’s stack at the bottom of your stack. Record the name of each student who submits an essay at this time. [If anyone turns in this assignment after you have collected it, please write the word LATE and the time at which he or she submitted the work to you.]
- B. Tell anyone who has not turned in a paper to take his or her things and move to one of the tables in the room to work alone. Redistribute the papers for peer review. Start in the middle row so that no one gets his or her own paper back.
- C. Instruct students to take out their assignment packets for this essay and to remove the review form from it. Tell them to use the review form to evaluate the essay they are reading. Remind them to write precise and thorough answers in order to give the writer as much help as possible. Allow about 15 - 20 min. for this activity. Monitor this time and work carefully so that you can move on to the next step early if everyone finishes before 15 or 20 minutes have elapsed.
- D. When everyone has completed the peer review exercise, instruct students to return the essay and the review form to the writer of the essay they read.
- E. Students should use the rest of the time to revise their essay. Remind them to read the instructions at the end of the review form carefully.
Assignment for next class meeting: Complete the final draft of the assigned essay.
Day 6
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have completed the final draft of the assigned essay.
Activities:
- A. Collect the essays by instructing the students to pass forward their papers, placing theirs on the top of the stack as the stacks come forward. This will keep them in alphabetical order. Then collect the papers starting at your left, and placing each row’s stack at the bottom of your stack. Record the name of each student who submits an essay at this time. [If anyone turns in this assignment after you have collected it, please write the word LATE and the time at which he or she submitted the work to you.]
- B. Go over the following points of contrast between the Middle Ages and the Renaissance.
-
1. Chief emphasis
- a. Middle Ages: the moral sense, the motivation toward salvation and a heavenly reward directed concern and energy toward behavior.
- b. The Renaissance: the esthetic sense, though they did not abandon their Christianity, the people of the Renaissance became interested in pleasing appearances, charm, grace, and spectacle.
-
2. Dominant philosophy
- a. Middle Ages: Scholasticism - as developed and applied by St. Thomas Aquinas - was a systematic method of thinking. Aquinas used his philosophical system to combine the theology of the Bible - the principal text of the Middle Ages - with the philosophy of Aristotle, the ancient Greek philosopher whom Aquinas and his contemporaries most admired.
- b. The Renaissance: Humanism - as promoted (though never truly organized, as was Scholasticism) by Francesco Petrarca (Petrarch) - was a loose set of goals or aspirations focused on studying the literature and history of classical antiquity and appreciating the human spirit.
-
3. Dominant economic and political form
- a. Middle Ages: feudalism, a system in which the basis for and measure of wealth is land. In that system the king holds title to all land, giving over the profits from portions of it to his nobles in exchange for their commitment to protect. They, in turn, gave over some of their land and its profits to knights under the same agreement. Only the serfs had no profits, for they belonged to land just as all they produced belonged to their overlord.
- b. The Renaissance: capitalism, a system in which the basis for and measure of wealth is money.
-
4. Dominant art style
- a. Middle Ages: Gothic
- 1) In architecture, it emphasizes vertical lines - lines that reach toward Heaven - the life beyond this life.
- 2) In music, it emphasizes listening to the Gregorian chants of a church service.
- 3) In painting, it emphasizes stylization and symbolism. It has a flat, two-dimensional effect. The haloes on saints and angels look more like golden plates held up behind their heads.
- b. Renaissance: Renaissance [Yes, the style takes its name from the period.]
- 1) In architecture, it emphasizes horizontal lines - lines that parallel the earth, emphasizing the here and now.
- 2) In music, it emphasizes participation. Men and women of the upper class learned to play the lute or recorder, and they all sang - as expression of their personalities.
- 3) In painting, it emphasizes three-dimensionality and an accurate representation of the natural world - the way people actually look.
- a. Middle Ages: Gothic
-
5. Dominant social attitudes
a. Middle Ages b. Renaissance 1) community-oriented 1) individualistic 2) specialists 2) generalists 3) spiritual 3) realistic 4) placed women on pedestals 4) women reached toward greater equality
-
- C. Go over the following details about life in the Renaissance.
- 1. The Italian term for the generalist/individualist of the period is uomo universale.
- 2. The uomo universale was often primarily an artist who needed a PATRON.
- 3. The patron was often a man who longed to be an uomo universale but who lacked the intellectual power to achieve his goal. Consequently, he satisfied his longing by surrounding himself with those who could master many things, using his money to help them.
- 4. Many patrons came from the rising middle class. While in the Middle Ages only two classes had existed: the wealthy nobility and the impoverished serfs. As the Renaissance began, merchants and artisans began to accumulate money and power; they became the new class - what we call the middle class.
- 5. The BLACK PLAGUE also contributed to the rise of the Renaissance. It killed off the nobility who owned the serfs who then sought new lives in the cities.
- 6. The greatest concentration of uomini universali could be found in the Italian city of Florence, “The Queen of the Renaissance.”
Assignment for next class meeting: Read “Petrarch as a Renaissance Man” and Petrarch’s “Letter to Posterity.”
Day 7
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read “Petrarch as a Renaissance Man” and Petrarch’s “Letter to Posterity.”
Activities:
- A. Administer quiz over the reading. [These can be found in the third drawer of the filing cabinet - LABELLED 3 - in a pink-tabbed folder labelled “Petrarch” toward the front of the drawer.]
- B. Go over the answers to the study questions. [The following are, for the most part, drawn directly from the essays. Use my responses to guide the students’ responses.]
Petrarch as a Renaissance Man
- 1. What is Petrarch’s most strikingly Renaissance quality?
His work has a certain “self-centered quality…Petrarch was continuously at work on his personal drama, on its lights and shades, on all of its subtle modulations of feeling.”
- 2. What makes him “the first writer of the Renaissance”?
“His attitude toward classical antiquity makes him the first writer of the Renaissance.”
What served as the model for his work?
“he modeled his work on classical examples, those texts which, as a humanistic scholar, he had helped to rediscover and bring back to life.”
- 3. What is his three-part contribution (along with Boccaccio) to Western civilization?
He established the model of the poet, the scholar, and the member of the “republic of letters.” His conception of the poet is that of the man who celebrates his passions in carefully worked verse. The scholar devotes himself to a broad pursuit of knowledge. The member of the “republic of letters” is the person who represents an international community of literate, learned intellectuals.
- 4. What was Petrarch’s status in his own time?
He was a prominent man, well known throughout Western Europe.
What are his three principal professional pursuits?
He was a courtier (one who served some function in a noble court and lived there at the lord’s expense), a diplomat, and a man of letters (a learned man).
What humanist advantage did he take as he travelled throughout Europe?
He searched for ancient writings and expressed his self-image assertively.
- 5. To what extent was Petrarch “image-conscious”?
He consciously worked at creating an image of himself expressed through his poems and letters, both of which he carefully polished and organized before publishing.
- 6. What remarkable “accidents” occurred in Petrarch’s life?
Petrarch saw Laura for the first time on April 6, 1327. Then, twenty-one years later, she died on the same day in April.
How did he turn them to poetic use?
He used that Easter (or Passion Sunday as it is called throughout Europe) as a metaphor for his own earthly passion for Laura.
- 7. What elements provide Petrarch’s love of Laura with a tragic tone?
Repeatedly in his sonnets, Petrarch alludes to the sinfulness and vanity of his love for Laura. He asserts an ambiguity of the “attractions of mortal beauty and earthly values.”
How does Petrarch define love?
Petrarch defines love as an emotion perfected only in sorrow. [His view is quite similar to that held by the medieval romancers.]
What role does Laura play in death?
In death, Laura becomes “the mediator between the penitent poet and Divine Grace” (reminiscent of Beatrice’s role in Dante’s epic).
Letter to Posterity
- 1. What is the irony of Petrarch’s opening sentence (especially in relationship to the title)?
Though he claims that he will be unremembered, he spends a great deal of effort on recording details of his life for the future (posterity) to read.
Of the second sentence of the second paragraph?
Though he claims to be of humble origins, his reference to Augustus Caesar connects him to a noble name in history.
Of the first sentence of the fifth paragraph?
Though he asserts that he has always regarded himself as somewhat insignificant, he records the details of a number of his relationships with the nobility as well as the bestowal of the laureate on him for his achievements as a poet.
Of the last sentence of paragraph seven?
While he protests the vanity of elegant language, he was noted in his own time and today for his efforts to polish his language for optimum effect.
Of the fourth sentence in the final paragraph?
The man who has spent most of his letter declaring his simplicity and humility compares his treatment by Giacomo the Younger of Carrara to that received by souls in Heaven.
- 2. To what does Petrarch attribute people’s judgments of others?
He says, “in passing judgment almost everyone is influenced not so much by truth as by whim; there is no measure for praise or blame.”
Do the content and tone of his letter bear out this view?
No. In fact, his record of his relationships with other people invariably points up their considered evaluation and appreciation of him and his work.
- 3. Do you believe the third sentence of the second paragraph? The last sentence in the fifth paragraph?
This is, of course, an OPEN QUESTION. However, careful reading indicates that Petrarch was actually somewhat proud of his friends and of his accomplishments. The second sentence noted asserts his aversion to associating with the nobility; however, the rest of the letter recounts their respect for and fine treatment of him.
- 4. What image of his social self does he present - especially in paragraphs three and four?
In these paragraphs he asserts his humble origins.
He next notes his “great contempt for money.” Yet he does admit that it does not arise from any aversion to being rich but to the “work and care which are invariably associated with wealth.”
He claims to have “lead a happier life with a plain diet and ordinary foods.” In conjunction with that attitude, he says that he dislikes banquets because of the rude behavior and drunkenness.
However, he does like to spend time with friends in dinner conversation.
He asserts that “nothing annoys [him] more than display…because it is disturbing and distracting.”
In the fourth paragraph he alludes to his love for Laura without naming her and to his ambiguous attraction to such passion and aversion from desires of the flesh.
- 5. How does Petrarch explain his interest in antiquity?
He says that “I always disliked [my] own age - so much so, that had it not been for the love of those dear to me. I would have preferred to have been born in any other time than my own. In order to forget my own times, I have always tried to place myself mentally in another age; thus I delighted in history…”
- 6. When and why did Petrarch abandon the study of law?
After seven years of studying law, Petrarch left his studies “as soon as it was no longer necessary to follow the wishes of my parents.”
In his own words, he gave up pursuing a career in law “because I felt it was being continuously degraded by those who practice it. I hated the idea of learning an art which I would not practice dishonestly, and could hardly hope to practice otherwise.”
- 7. What family served as Petrarch’s first patrons?
The Colonna family served as his first patrons.
What is the title and subject of Petrarch’s epic poem?
He worked on an epic poem called Africa on the life of Scipio Africanus.
What is the story of Petrarch’s being named poet laureate? [What is a poet laureate?]
According to Petrarch he received letters from both the Roman Senate and the Chancellor at the University of Paris offering him the laurel crown in recognition for his achievements as a poet. He admits to his youthful conviction that he deserved the honor. [However, he does not explain how he lobbied both parties to get them to offer it to him, nor how he most wanted the prize to come from Rome - the seat of his personal Golden Age.]
Who, at least according to Petrarch, validated the poet’s right to the prize?
Petrarch claims that he sought the advice of Cardinal Giovanni Colonna who advised him to accept the Roman offer.
Assignment for next class meeting: In the Renaissance packet read the information on the Petrarchan sonnet form.
Day 8
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read the information on the Petrarchan sonnet form.
Activities:
-
A. Administer quiz over the reading. [These can be found in the third drawer of the filing cabinet - LABELLED 3 - in a pink-tabbed folder labelled “Sonnets” toward the front of the drawer.]
-
B. Discuss Petrarchan sonnet form.
-
1. Go over the definition of any sonnet:
The SONNET is a lyric poem of fourteen lines written in iambic pentameter and following a prescribed rhyme scheme.
-
2. Note the two major types of sonnets.
The ITALIAN (or PETRARCHAN) and the ENGLISH (or SHAKESPEAREAN).
-
3. Point out that the Italian or Petrarchan sonnet has two parts:
The OCTAVE - the first eight lines of the poem
The SESTET - the final six lines of the poem
-
4. The rhyme scheme prescribed for the OCTAVE is abbaabba; for the SESTET is cdecde, or cdccdc, or cdedce, or any pattern that avoids a concluding couplet (ee).
-
5. The design of the sonnet calls on the OCTAVE to present a story, state a proposition, raise a question, or the like the SESTET to comment on the story, apply the proposition, solve the problem, or in some way respond to the octave. The point between the OCTAVE and the SESTET when the emphasis or approach or tone switches is called the VOLTA (in Italian, the “turning point”).
-
6. IAMBIC PENTAMETER consists of lines with…
TEN SYLLABLES: the first, third, fifth, seventh, and ninth syllables are UNSTRESSED, while the second, fourth, sixth, eighth, and tenth syllables are STRESSED.
The line is scanned (diagrammed) in this way:
˘ / ˘ / ˘ / ˘ / ˘ /
EXAMPLE:
O ye who in these scat tered rhymes may hear a
The ech oes of the sighs that fed my heart b
In er rant youth, for I was then, in part, b
An oth er man from what I now ap pear, a
-
-
C. Go over the answers to the study questions. [I have copied the poems here to help you discuss the answers to the questions which follow each poem.]
It Was the Morning
It was the morning of that blessed day
Whereon the Sun in pity veiled his glare
For the Lord’s agony, that, unaware,
I fell a captive, Lady, to the sway
Of your swift eyes: that seemed no time to stay
The strokes of Love: I stepped into the snare
Secure, with no suspicion: then, and there
I found my cue in man’s most tragic play.
Love caught me naked to his shaft, his sheaf,
The entrance for his ambush and surprise
Against the heart wide open through the eyes,
The constant gate and fountain of my grief:
How craven so to strike me stricken so,
Yet from you fully armed conceal his bow!
- 1. What is the holy day referred to in lines 1-3?
The holy day is Good Friday because “the Lord’s agony” refers to the Crucifixion.
To what event does “the Lord’s agony” refer?
According to tradition, that day was overcast - the sun did not shine; hence, “the Sun in pity veiled his glare” (line 2). [The day is called “blessed” (line 1) because it is through the act of dying that Christians believe that Christ saved them.]
Consequently, why does Petrarch refer to himself as “stricken so” in line 13?
Petrarch refers to himself as “stricken so” because - like most Christians - he grieves for his Lord’s sacrifice on its anniversary.
- 2. To whom does Lady refer in line 4?
Since he speaks of falling “a captive…to [her] sway” (line 4), the Lady must be Laura.
- 3. What is the special meaning of stay in line 5?
In this instance stay means “to stop or delay the effect of.” [Petrarch is saying that the anniversary of the greatest act of love of all time seemed no time to stop or delay any love.]
- 4. What imagery does Petrarch use in lines 6, 9, 10, and 14 to describe his view of love?
The words strokes, snare, shaft, sheaf, ambush, fully armed, and bow are images from hunting and/or battle.
What are a shaft and a sheaf in this case?
The shaft is the long, narrow stem of an arrow; the sheaf is an archer’s quiver of arrows.
[Strokes are “blows”; a snare is a “trap” as is an ambush; fully armed and bow should be self-explanatory.]
- 5. According to line 11 what is the gateway to the heart?
According to line 11 (and Renaissance lore) the eyes are the gateway to the heart.
How does this idea help to explain the meaning of lines 4 and 5?
Since sway here means “dominion or control,” Petrarch must be saying that Laura’s eyes quickly took control of his heart.
Why does Petrarch also refer to that “gate” as a “fountain”?
In line 12 Petrarch calls the eyes the “gate and fountain of [his] grief” because the eyes are the exit (“gate”) and source (“fountain”) of tears, visible expressions of grief. [Remember that Petrarch’s definition of love calls for an element of sorrow.]
- 6. Paraphrase the sonnet in your own prose.
THIS IS AN OPEN QUESTION, but here is a possible response:
While I was at mass on the morning of Good Friday, I first saw you, Laura. That did not seem the appropriate time or place to think of fending off love. Consequently, I fell into the trap called love, following the example of Him who died for love. [“I found my cue in man’s most tragic play.”] Like a hunter or an armed warrior, love made a successful attack on me, but did not attack you. I fell, but you did not.
Blest Be the Day
Blest be the day, and blest the month and year,
Season and hour and very moment blest,
The lovely land and place* where first possessed
By two pure eyes I found me prisoner;
And blest the first sweet pain, the first most dear,
Which burnt my heart when Love came in as guest;
And blest the bow, the shafts which shook my breast,
And even the wounds which Love delivered there.
Blest be the words and voices which filled grove
And glen with echoes of my lady’s name;
The sighs, the tears, the fierce despair of love;
And blest the sonnet-sources of my fame;
And blest that thought of thoughts which is her own
Of her, her only, of herself alone!
*the Church of St. Clare in Avignon
- 1. Has the translator adhered to the rhyme scheme of the Petrarchan octave?
No, though the octave does technically follow the abbaabba pattern, it resorts to near (instead of true) rhymes in the case of “prisoner” (line 4) and “there” (line 8).
Has he adhered to the rhyme scheme of the Petrarchan sestet?
The sestet departs even further: not only does it use near rhymes - “grove” (line 9) and “love” (line 11), it ends in a couplet, a rhyme not allowed in the Petrarchan form.
- 2. Which words (and in which lines) of the poem refer to the same imagery of love that Petrarch used in “It Was the Morning”?
Prisoner (line 4), Pain (line 5), burnt (line 6), shafts (line 7), and wounds (line 8) recall the hunter/warrior imagery.
What new words (and in which lines) add to that imagery?
The phrases “possessed/By two pure eyes,” (lines 3-4), “the first sweet pain,” (line 5), and “the fierce despair of love” (line 11) recall Petrarch’s vision of love as best when it includes an element of sorrow.
- 3. Which line in the sestet best reflects Petrarch’s self-centeredness?
Line 12 is clearly a reference to his image as the premier poet of his generation. In it he acknowledges the fame his poetry about his tragic love has brought him.
Father in Heaven
Father in heaven, after each lost day,
Each night spent raving with that fierce desire
Which in my heart has kindled into fire
Seeing your acts adorned for my dismay;
Grant henceforth that I turn, within your light
To another life and deeds more truly fair,
So having spread to no avail the snare
My bitter foe might hold it in despite.
The eleventh year, my Lord, has now come round
Since I was yoked beneath the heavy trace
That on the meekest weighs most cruelly.
Pity the abject plight where I am found;
Return my straying thoughts to a nobler place;
Show them this day you were on Calvary.
- 1. What does trace mean in line 10?
A trace is one of two side chains connecting a harnessed draft animal to the vehicle it pulls. Petrarch uses it to create the image of love as constraining, as weighing down the heart of the lover.
- 2. What does Petrarch claim he would prefer to the passion he feels for Laura?
He prays to “Return [his] straying thoughts to a nobler place” (line 13). That place is likely a reference to church, since that is where he was when he first saw Laura. Line 14 underscores that idea.
Assignment for next class meeting: Read the sonnets in the Petrarch packet and answer the assigned study questions for each sonnet.
Day 9
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read all the sonnets in the Petrarch packet and answered the assigned study questions for each sonnet.
Activities:
- A. Administer quiz over the reading. [These can be found in the third drawer of the filing cabinet - LABELLED 3 - in a pink-tabbed folder labelled “Sonnets” toward the front of the drawer.]
- B. Go over the answers to the study questions. [I have copied the poems here to help you discuss the answers to the questions which follow each poem.]
She Used to Let Her Golden Hair Fly Free
She used to let her golden hair fly free
For the wind to toy and tangle and molest;
Her eyes were brighter than the radiant west.
(Seldom they shine so now.) I used to see
Pity look out of those deep eyes on me.
(“It was false pity,” you would now protest.)
I had love’s tinder heaped within my breast.
What wonder that the flame burned furiously?
She did not walk in any mortal way,
But with angelic progress; when she spoke
Unearthly voices sang in unison.
She seemed divine among the dreary folk
Of earth. You say she is not so today?
Well, though the bow’s unbent, the wound bleeds on.
- 1. What detail in this poem recalls one of Durant’s comments about the concept of feminine beauty in the Renaissance?
Line 1 refers to the fact Durant reports - that the ideal hair color of the Italian Renaissance was blonde.
The Eyes That Drew From Me
The eyes that drew from me such fervent praise
The arms and hands and feet and countenance
Which made me a stranger in my own romance
And set me apart from the well-trodden ways.
The gleaming golden curly hair, the rays
Flashing from a smiling angel’s glance
Which moved the world in paradisal dance,
Are grains of dust, insensibilities.
And I live on, but in grief and self-contempt
Left here without the light I loved so much,
In a great tempest and with shrouds unkempt.
No more love songs, then, I have done with such;
My old skill now runs thin at each attempt,
And tears are heard within the harp I touch.
- 1. What is the subject of the octave?
The subject of the octave is Laura’s eyes - and the fact that they are gone because she is dead: They “Are grains of dust” (line 8).
What is the tone of the octave?
The tone is that of a fond memory.
- 2. What is the subject of the sestet?
The subject of the sestet is Petrarch’s feeling of loss - of Laura and of his “old skill,” (line 13) his talent for writing poetry.
What is the tone of the sestet?
Grief, remorse, self-contempt, and a measure of self-pity describe the tone of the sestet.
- 3. What is the irony of line 12?
Though he says, “No more love songs, then, I have done with such,” this sonnet is clearly a love song - and many more will follow.
- 4. Does the translator maintain the true Petrarchan rhyme scheme?
Except for the reliance on a near rhyme in line 8, this translator does succeed in reproducing the Petrarchan rhyme scheme: abbaabba cdcdcd.
Great Is My Envy of You
Great is my envy of you, earth, in your greed
Folding her in invisible embrace,
Denying me the look of the sweet face
Where I found peace from all my strife at need!
Great is my envy of heaven which can lead
And lock within itself in avarice
That spirit from its lovely hiding-place
And leave so many others here to bleed!
Great is my envy of those souls whose reward
Is the gentle heaven of her company,
Which I so fiercely sought beneath these skies!
Great is my envy of death whose curt hard sword
Carried her whom I called my life away;
Me he disdains, and mocks me from her eyes!
- 1. Of whom is Petrarch envious in the first half of the octave?
He is envious of the earth because it holds Laura’s body in an everlasting embrace.
In the second half?
In the second half of the octave he envies Heaven because it possesses Laura’s spirit.
In the first half of the sestet?
In the first half of the sestet, he envies the other souls in Heaven who enjoy her company, something he longed for but never achieved in life.
In the second half?
In the second half of the sestet, he envies death who “carried [Laura] away.” He speaks of death as another man might speak of a rival for a woman’s love.
- 2. How are the words embrace and avarice used ironically?
In line 2 the word embrace is a word that actually refers to an intensely affectionate caress, but here Petrarch uses it to describe interment (burial). It is the earth that surrounds her as a lover’s arms would have in life. [The embrace is invisible because we cannot see through the surface of the earth.]
Avarice names the sin of greed. Since Heaven is the domain of blessed reward, the irony seems quite clear.
- 3. Does the translator adhere to the Petrarchan rhyme scheme?
The rhyme scheme comes close to the Petrarchan form, but it depends on near rhymes for line 6 in the octave and for lines 9 and 12 and lines 10 and 13 in the sestet.
Go, Grieving Rimes of Mine
Go, grieving rimes of mine, to that hard stone
Whereunder lies my darling, lies my dear,
And cry to her to speak from heaven’s sphere,
Her mortal part with grass is overgrown.
Tell her, I’m sick of living; that I’m blown
By winds of grief from the course I ought to steer,
That praise of her is all my purpose here
And all my business; that of her alone.
Do I go telling, that how she lived and died
And lives again in immortality,
All men may know, and love my Laura’s grace.
Oh, may she deign to stand at my bedside
When I come to die; and may she call to me
And draw me to her in the blessed place!
- 1. What are rimes?
Rime is a variant spelling of rhyme when it means rhymed poetry.
To what does Petrarch refer by the expression “that hard stone”?
“That hard stone” (line 1) is Laura’s tombstone.
What is “Her mortal part”?
“Her mortal part” (line 4) is Laura’s body.
- 2. What part of Dante’s Inferno do lines 5-6 recall?
Petrarch’s love for Laura had been a most sensual one. She was NOT his wife or even his betrothed. Technically, such sensuality qualifies as lust. In Inferno, Dante describes the lustful as punished by being eternally blown about by a whirlwind - just as their lust “swept them off their feet.” Petrarch refers to being “blown/By winds of grief.” Surely the lustful lovers in Dante’s Second Circle grieved mightily.
- 3. According to lines 9-11, what are Petrarch’s motives for publishing the Canzoniere (the collection of poems inspired by Laura)?
He asserts that he wrote and published all the sonnets about her in order to bestow upon her a kind of immortality. He suggests that she lives again each time someone reads about her and his love for her.
- 4. What does deign mean?
Deign means “to think it appropriate or suitable to one’s dignity to do something.” It can also mean “to condescend to give or grant.”
What is Petrarch’s final wish?
Petrarch’s final wish is that Laura’s blessed spirit might feel it appropriate to lower herself to come to him at the moment of his own death and conduct his soul to Heaven.
- 5. Does the translator maintain the true Petrarchan rhyme scheme?
Yes, the rhyme scheme follows the true Petrarchan abbaabba cdecde.
Assignment for next class meeting: Begin to write your own Petrarchan sonnet on a romantic theme. Read “Life of Messer Giovanni Boccaccio,” the author’s preface and the introduction to The Decameron.
Day 10
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read “Life of Messer Giovanni Boccaccio,” the author’s preface and the introduction to The Decameron. They should also have prepared the assigned study questions.
Activities:
- A. Administer quiz over the reading. [These can be found in the third drawer of the filing cabinet - LABELLED 3 - in a pink-tabbed folder labelled “Boccaccio I” toward the front of the drawer.]
- B. Go over the answers to the study questions.
THE LIFE OF BOCCACCIO BY LODOVICO DOLCE
- 1. Summarize Boccaccio’s personality as related by Dolce. Be thorough and explanatory. [Consider his relationship with his father and his education.] Include physical characteristics.
Dolce portrays Boccaccio as a haughty, proud person who genuinely despised princely patrons, but did like King Robert of Naples.
Boccaccio was truly of humble Florentine origins. He rejected both the life of a merchant and that of a lawyer, resisting his father’s wishes for him. He preferred poetry and oratory. Though he never married, he was survived by an illegitimate son.
- 2. Discuss Boccaccio’s relationship with Maria. Who was she?
Boccaccio loved Maria, the daughter of Robert of Naples.
Who was Fiammetta? How does the relationship relate to Ovid?
He called her Fiammetta in the tradition of Ovid’s calling his love Corinna to protect her identity.
To Dante?
Like Dante, he took her as his inspiration.
To Petrarch?
Like Petrarch, he saw her for the first time in church. However, their relationship was far from either spiritual or primarily artistic.
Do you see any unromantic aspects to the story of their relationship?
The last question is definitely OPEN. However, I find Maria’s beheading when she was sick and old, not long after Boccaccio’s death somewhat unromantic.
- 3. Summarize Boccaccio’s relationship with Petrarch.
Boccaccio held a deep and abiding respect for Petrarch. They exchanged friendship rings and literary encouragement. Boccaccio brought Petrarch back to Florence.
AUTHOR’S PREFACE
- 1. What are the title and the sub-title of Boccaccio’s book?
The title is Decameron. The sub-title is Prince Galeotto, a reference to the knight who served as the go-between for Sir Launcelot and Queen Guinevere.
- 2. What does Boccaccio have to say about the strength of hidden love?
He says that hidden love exceeds expressed love in strength.
What does he say about a woman’s suffering for love?
He also says that a woman’s suffering exceeds a man’s.
- 3. What does he declare the purpose of his book to be?
He states that the purpose of his book is to offer pleasure and counsel to suffering ladies to soothe their melancholy.
AUTHOR’S INTRODUCTION
- 1. What is the setting of the Decameron: place and time?
The frame story is set in Florence in 1348 during the reign of the plague.
- 2. What precautions had been taken by the city regarding the black plague?
The city handled the removal of garbage and waste. New laws prohibited the entry of the sick into the city and issued directives concerning the maintenance of good health.
What were its symptoms? [Be sure to explain what gavoccioli and buboes are.]
The symptoms started with swellings (gavoccioli or buboes) in the groin or armpits. These spread throughout the body. Variously sized black spots all over the body followed. Because they knew of no cure, most of those infected died after three days - often with no other side effects.
How was it spread?
The disease spread by contact with the sick or their clothes or their animals.
- 3. Summarize BRIEFLY the effects the plague had on daily life.
People began to avoid the sick fearfully. Small groups lived apart, surviving on a restricted diet, avoiding even discussion of the plague. Others chose to carouse, making light of everything. A growing sense of doom led people to abandon their property to flee the disease. Respect for the law almost disappeared. On the other hand, many took a more moderate approach. They carried flowers and herbs “to [purify] the brain.” The sick had to rely on the charity of friends or the avarice of servants. This turn indicates a decline in compassion.
Define becchini.
Boccaccio also notes the near disappearance of feminine modesty, linking this change to the subsequent decline in morals of which Durant speaks. Clergymen abbreviated funerals, and mourning rituals almost disappeared. Mass graves replaced individual plots. The lower class had a booming new occupation as becchini, gravediggers.
- 4. A FRAME STORY is a story that is used to explain why a collection of other stories are told or a play performed. Name the seven women who are the characters in the Decameron’s frame story. Summarize BRIEFLY their personalities: age, rank, appearance, intelligence, and behavior.
It will be sufficient for the students to offer an over all summary of the ladies’ personalities by noting that they are all young (between 18 and 28), noble (in birth), beautiful, educated, well-mannered, and gracefully modest. [Each is also a friend, a neighbor, or a relative of at least one of the others.]
In case students respond more fully, I have also provided a fuller breakdown along with the ladies’ names:
Their names are PAMPINEA: wise, confident, often in love, most mature
FIAMMETTA: happy to love and be loved; afraid she will lose her love
FILOMENA: wise, discreet, full of desire
EMILIA: in love with herself
LAURETTA: a jealous lover
NEIFILE: young, ingenuous
ELISSA: very young, dominated by violent passion
- 5. Of the women, who suggests they escape to the country?
PAMPINEA suggests they escape to the country (motivated by a sense of self-preservation as well as fear of both the disease and the moral decline).
Who believes they need male guidance [which two]?
Both FILOMENA and ELISSA call for male guidance. Filomena points out feminine faults such as quarrelsomeness, suspicion, timidity, and fearfulness. Elissa believes their presence would forestall scandal.
Who fears scandal?
NEIFILE, however, fears the men’s presence will foment scandal since each man is the lover of one of the women.
Who discounts what others may think?
FILOMENA answers Neifile by saying she discounts what others think if she knows she lives with dignity and a clear conscience.
- 6. Name the three men.
The three men are PANFILO, FILOSTRATO, and DIONEO.
How are they related to the women?
Each is the lover of one of the women and a relative of another.
- 7. What is the plan for organizing each day? Who suggests rounds of storytelling?
Pampinea calls for organization. Each of the ten should take a turn as the day’s “ruler” (the first elected, the successors to be appointed by each ruler in turn). The ruler will oversee the servants and the accomplishment of chores. Pampinea ends by suggesting that they pass the time by each telling a story every day.
Assignment for next class meeting: Read “First Day, Second Story,” and “Fourth Day, Fifth Story.” Prepare assigned study questions.
Day 11
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read “First Day, Second Story,” and “Fourth Day, Fifth Story.” They should also have prepared assigned study questions.
Activities:
- A. Administer quiz over the reading. [These can be found in the third drawer of the filing cabinet - LABELLED 3 - in a pink-tabbed folder labelled “Boccaccio II” toward the front of the drawer.]
- B. Go over the answers to the study questions.
FIRST DAY, SECOND STORY
- 1. Identify the two characters.
The two main characters are Abraham and Giannotto di Civigni.
Explain their personalities in as much detail as possible, citing specific references from the story as well as drawing inferences from the information supplied.
Abraham is a Jewish merchant, an upright, trustworthy person, devoted to his faith.
Giannotto is a Christian merchant, an honest and upright man, devoted to his faith as well. He longs to see his dear friend, Abraham, converted to Christianity.
- 2. What is Boccaccio’s view of churchmen?
Boccaccio seems to view his contemporary churchmen as corrupt.
Which details of the story support your answer?
When Neifile introduces her story, she states her theme. “I intend to show you how … mercy patiently endures the faults of those who with their words and deeds ought to bear witness to this mercy and yet do the contrary…”
Giannotto seems to speak for Boccaccio’s view when the merchant says, “I have wasted my time which I thought I had employed so well, believing that I might have converted him, but if he goes to the court of Rome and sees the wicked and filthy lives of the clergy, not only will he not become a Christian from a Jew, but if he were to have become a Christian before, he would, without a doubt, return to being a Jew.”
In his narration of Abraham’s visit to Rome, he records the following. “While he was living there,…[he] began carefully to observe the behavior of the Pope, the cardinals, and the other prelates and courtiers; and from what he heard and saw for himself - he was a very perceptive man - from the highest to the lowest of them, they all in general shamelessly participated in the sin of lust,…[gluttony], [drunkenness], [avarice] and [simony].”
- 3. What is Boccaccio’s opinion of Jews, based on his treatment of Abraham in this story? (Be careful not to confuse Boccaccio’s treatment of Abraham with Giannotto’s fears.) What details support your answer?
At the very least, Boccaccio seems to possess a tolerance for Judaism altogether uncharacteristic of the time. He praises Abraham’s trustworthiness and uprightness as well as his perceptiveness and over all intelligence.
- 4. What function does irony play in this story? Do you consider the last sentence to be in any way ironic?
Since Giannotto believes that a trip to Rome will seal Abraham’s life-long devotion to Judaism, it is ironic that that very trip leads to the man’s conversion to Christianity.
- 5. Does this story relate to our time in any way? How or how not?
This is an OPEN QUESTION. Encourage the students to speak up.
FOURTH DAY, FIFTH STORY
- 1. Who is the protagonist of the story?
The principal character, the PROTAGONIST, is Isabetta, a young woman in love with a man of lower social rank than herself.
How does Boccaccio build sympathy for her? Which details from the story support your answer?
To build sympathy for Isabetta, Boccaccio begins by describing her as a “beautiful and accomplished young girl.” She also follows her heart instead of social convention. He details the grief that overwhelms her when Lorenzo disappears. Perhaps most persuasive is the way her heart and mind snap when she discovers Lorenzo’s corpse.
Who are the antagonists? How does Boccaccio create resentment against them?
He also builds sympathy for her by describing her brothers, the ANTAGONISTS in quite unsympathetic terms. For example, they see Isabetta’s love for Lorenzo only in terms of the affair’s effects on them - in particular, shame, NOT in terms of Isabetta’s feelings. Their cold-blooded killing, of course, only compounds our disgust for them. Furthermore, they respond to Isabetta’s inquiries regarding Lorenzo with anger but without information.
- 2. What can you learn about the social relationship between men and women within a family - from reading this story?
The plot makes clear that the men in a family felt that they had power and responsibility over the women in the family. They seem also to feel that women need not be consulted about their relationships or lives, especially insofar as their love life was concerned.
Which details support your answer?
Their sense of personal shame and arbitrary decision to murder Lorenzo both indicate their proprietorial treatment of Isabetta.
- 3. How does the view of love expressed by Boccaccio in this story differ from the view of love expressed by Petrarch in his sonnets? Does it differ?
Petrarch celebrates the concept of love at first sight. Though the two lovers in this story fall in love quickly, they still see each other “several times” before they commit themselves to their love. On the other hand, Isabetta expresses the same kind of grief that Petrarch claims to feel when Laura dies. Both Boccaccio’s story and Petrarch’s sonnets create a picture of love in which an element of sorrow or tragedy is most significant.
- 4. Does this story relate to our own time in any way? How or how not?
This is an OPEN QUESTION. Please encourage the students to share their responses.
Assignment for next class meeting: Read “Fifth Day, Ninth Story,” “Tenth Day, Tenth Story,” and the author’s conclusion. Prepare assigned study questions.
Day 12
Assignment to have been completed: Students should have read “Fifth Day, Ninth Story,” “Tenth Day, Tenth Story,” and the author’s conclusion. They should also have prepared assigned study questions.
Activities:
- A. Administer quiz over the reading. [These can be found in the third drawer of the filing cabinet - LABELLED 3 - in a pink-tabbed folder labelled “Boccaccio III” toward the front of the drawer.]
- B. Go over the answers to the study questions.
FIFTH DAY, NINTH STORY
- 1. Though some might say the story reeks of sentimentality, others may recognize the story-teller’s art in Boccaccio’s use of conflict. Identify all the conflicts created in the story. How does each contribute toward complicating the plot? Which one provides the climactic decision? How is each resolved?
The first conflict operates between Federigo and Monna Giovanna: he loves her, but she does not love him. The conflict results in his impoverishing himself by trying to win her.
The second conflict arises when Monna Giovanna’s deathly ill son asks her to get Federigo to give him his prize falcon. The conflict lies in the fact that she had spurned Federigo for years, behavior that some might say drove him into poverty. Now her love for her son that tells her to get the falcon conflicts with her lack of love for and past treatment of Federigo.
A third conflict arises in light of the fact that Monna Giovanna knows that the falcon is Federigo’s only means of support. She wants the bird because she loves her son, but compassion resists depriving Federigo of his support.
The fourth conflict comes out when Federigo must face the fact that if he had not wasted his wealth wooing Monna Giovanna in the past, he would have plenty to serve her now that she has come to him.
The fifth and climactic conflict lies in the fact that Monna Giovanna has come for the falcon to save her son - a gift that Federigo would freely and happily give for both the boy’s and his own love’s sake, but in his poverty Federigo has already given her that very bird - to eat because he has nothing else to offer her.
The sixth conflict resides in Monna Giovanna’s reaction to Federigo’s having served her the falcon: grievous disappointment over the loss of the one thing that might save her son’s life on the one hand and sincere respect for the greatness of a spirit that could make such a romantic gesture.
The seventh and concluding conflict lies in Monna Giovanna’s decision to marry Federigo: she would prefer to remain a widow, but her brothers insist that she is too young to do so. In response, she declares that she would marry Federigo, the most generous man she knows.
- 2. How many different kinds of love are woven into the fabric of the story? Who is involved in each? To what extent do the various loves reveal the personalities of the principal characters, Federigo and Giovanna?
Federigo’s love for Monna Giovanna in the beginning of the story is UNREQUITED LOVE (one-sided love, love that the beloved does not return).
Monna Giovanna’s love for her son is MATERNAL LOVE (the love of a mother for her child, a love that usually transcends all other obstacles).
Federigo’s love for Monna Giovanna in the middle of the story proves to be a SELFLESS LOVE (a love that sacrifices even the lover’s most prized possession to please the beloved).
Monna Giovanna’s love for Federigo, the love that moves her to decide to marry him is SINCERE LOVE, love that is borne purely of respect for the spirit of the man than out of physical attraction or greed.
- 3. How is sacrifice a central theme of this story?
SELFLESS LOVE demands sacrifice. Boccaccio could not communicate that theme without including sacrifice in his story.
What sacrifices transpire? Which passages support your answer?
First, Federigo sacrifices his wealth (perhaps foolishly; at least, unwisely) in his attempt to impress and win Monna Giovanna.
Second, Federigo sacrifices his most prized possession to honor the woman whom he continues to love when she finally deigns to visit him. (Again, his sacrifice may be unwise, but it is impressive.)
Finally, Monna Giovanna sacrifices her pride to marry Federigo though she would prefer to remain a widow.
- 4. Is love ennobling?
If self-sacrifice is a noble act, and if love led Federigo to sacrifice his wealth and his most prized possession, then love is ennobling.
Which details support your answer?
More illustrative of this point, however, is the effect that sincere love has on Monna Giovanna. Her respect for Federigo’s greatness of spirit leads her to marry him even though the fact that he served her the falcon her son felt he needed in order to recover may have led to the boy’s death makes her far more noble than any rank, beauty, or wealth she possesses.
- 5. How does Boccaccio use ambiguity in dealing with the boy’s death? Why?
Boccaccio says, “either because of his disappointment that he could not have the falcon, or because his illness must have necessarily led to it, the boy passed from life…”
If the boy had lived, Monna could never have inherited the wealth her husband left. Consequently, she could never have restored Federigo’s fortunes by marrying him. However, if the boy clearly died because he did not get Federigo’s falcon, then Monna Giovanna - who clearly loved her son, could never have considered marrying Federigo.
TENTH DAY, TENTH STORY
- 1. Describe the personality of Gualtieri in detail. Which details from the story support your description?
Gualtieri is a man who knows what he wants and does what he wants. He is bluntly direct in asking questions. He does not allow compassion to sway his decisions - especially not his test of Griselda. In fact, he conducts his test with a completely cold exterior although he clearly recognizes Griselda’s virtues.
Evaluate Gualtieri as a MAN by your own standards.
This is an OPEN QUESTION.
(Evaluate Gualtieri as a PERSON - not as a male - by your own standards.)
This is an OPEN QUESTION.
- 2. Describe the personality of Griselda in detail. Which details from the story support your description?
Griselda is an infinitely patient and submissive woman. She believes in the traditions of rank and gender supremacy. She shows great strength in face of the loss of her children whom she clearly loves. She also shows great respect for Gualtieri when she agrees to oversee the preparations for the arrival of his new wife. Finally, she does not react with anger or vengeance when Gualtieri reveals that the past twelve years of her life had been one long test of her wifely character.
Evaluate Griselda as a WOMAN by your own standards.
This is an OPEN QUESTION.
(Evaluate Griselda as a PERSON - not as a woman - by your own standards.)
This is an OPEN QUESTION.
- 3. According to Gualtieri what are the qualities of a good wife?
According to Gualtieri, a good wife should be obedient, never angry, and always pleasing to her husband.
- 4. Literature is filled with stories of tests from the story of Job to the story of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. Such stories remain popular even today. Is Gualtieri’s test of Griselda a fair test?
This is an OPEN QUESTION. It could tear the class apart if you do not monitor discussion closely.
What is its purpose?
According to Gualtieri his purpose was to “teach [Griselda] how to be a wife, to show [his vassals] how to know such a wife and how to choose and keep one, and to acquire for [himself] lasting tranquility.”
How might such a test be conducted today?
This question is OPEN too.
- 5. What is Boccaccio’s attitude toward Gualtieri?
Of Gualtieri, Boccaccio says spirits “more suited to governing pigs than to ruling over men make their appearances in royal palaces.” He adds, “It might have served Gualtieri right if he had run into the kind of woman who, once driven out of her home in nothing but a shift, would have allowed another man to shake her up to the point of getting herself a nice-looking dress out of the affair!”
Toward Griselda?
Of Griselda, he says “godlike spirits do sometimes rain down from heaven into poor homes.”
Assignment for next class meeting: Read “Basic Elements of the Arts - Elements of the Fine Arts” and “Judging a Work of Art.”